Best Detective Novels Classic (2026): 5 Picks Compared

The best detective novels classic readers return to star Sherlock Holmes, but the shelf holds newer series too. We compared five detective novels by classic fit, contents, value and series position, using only what the listings publish.

ShelfAnswers earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

The picks

#	Product	Shelf Score	Buy
1	Sherlock Holmes Vol I	9.8/10	Buy
2	Sherlock Holmes Vol II	9.8/10	Buy
3	Crimson Thaw by Coffin	9.6/10	Buy
4	Devil's Kitchen by Thielman	9.6/10	Buy
5	Unnatural Murder by Banner	9.6/10	Buy

1

Sherlock Holmes Vol I

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle·9.8/10 Shelf Score

i

The Shelf Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs fit for the reader or goal (35 points), contents and edition (25), value (25) and listed reading age or level (10, where the listing gives one), using only what the book listing states. How we pick ›

A 1088-page Bantam Classics volume with all 56 short stories and the early novels, starting with A Study in Scarlet.

Check price on Amazon

Pros

• 1088 pages, the longest book here, with 56 stories and 4 novels
• Bantam Classics edition, published November 1, 1986
• The definitive classic detective fiction per the description

Cons

• Victorian prose, not a modern read
• 1088 pages is a commitment
• Volume I only; Volume II completes the set

2

Sherlock Holmes Vol II

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle·9.8/10 Shelf Score

i

The Shelf Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs fit for the reader or goal (35 points), contents and edition (25), value (25) and listed reading age or level (10, where the listing gives one), using only what the book listing states. How we pick ›

A 768-page Bantam Classics volume with The Hound of the Baskervilles, The Valley of Fear and the later cases.

Check price on Amazon

Pros

• 768 pages including The Hound of the Baskervilles
• Bantam Classics edition, published December 1, 1986
• Book 2 of 2, completing the Holmes collection

Cons

• Victorian prose, not a modern read
• Volume II only; start with Volume I
• 1986 edition

3

Crimson Thaw by Coffin

Bruce Robert Coffin·9.6/10 Shelf Score

i

The Shelf Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs fit for the reader or goal (35 points), contents and edition (25), value (25) and listed reading age or level (10, where the listing gives one), using only what the book listing states. How we pick ›

Book 1 of 4 in the Detective Justice series: a disgraced Maine detective and a rookie solve a murder in Blue Hill.

Check price on Amazon

Pros

• Book 1 of 4, a clean series start
• Published November 4, 2025, the newest book here
• Severn River edition, a police procedural

Cons

• No page count is stated on the listing
• A modern procedural, not a classic
• No reading age is stated on the listing

4

Devil's Kitchen by Thielman

Mark Thielman·9.6/10 Shelf Score

i

The Shelf Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs fit for the reader or goal (35 points), contents and edition (25), value (25) and listed reading age or level (10, where the listing gives one), using only what the book listing states. How we pick ›

Book 1 of 4 in the Johnson and Nance Mysteries: a murder in Yellowstone tied to a centuries-old conspiracy.

Check price on Amazon

Pros

• Book 1 of 4, a clean series start
• Published April 1, 2025
• A blend of historical fiction and suspense per the description

Cons

• No page count is stated on the listing
• A modern mystery, not a classic
• No reading age is stated on the listing

5

Unnatural Murder by Banner

Blake Banner·9.6/10 Shelf Score

i

The Shelf Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs fit for the reader or goal (35 points), contents and edition (25), value (25) and listed reading age or level (10, where the listing gives one), using only what the book listing states. How we pick ›

Book 8 of 30 in the Dead Cold Mysteries: a shooting that connects to a fifteen-year-old cold case.

Check price on Amazon

Pros

• 222 pages, a stated page count
• Published November 17, 2024
• A cold-case structure for mystery fans

Cons

• Book 8 of 30, so new readers should start earlier
• A modern series, not a classic
• No reading age is stated on the listing

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

More picks to compare

• Hound of the Baskervilles128 pages, reading age 11+, Dover, 1994.Check on Amazon
• Rex Stout 10-Book SetNero Wolfe, 10 books, reading age 16+.Check on Amazon
• British Murder Mysteries Set350+ classics, reading age 12+, 2017.Check on Amazon
• Best Mystery ThrillersHolmes to Poe anthology, Grapevine, 2024.Check on Amazon
• Knox 5-Book CollectionGolden Age mysteries, reading age 16+.Check on Amazon

Compare the picks

Book details as published on each listing, collected 17 October 2026.

How we scored them

The Shelf Score weighs fit for a mystery reader, contents and edition, value, and the listed reading age or level where one is given. None of the five listings states a reading age. How we pick explains the weights.

Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each book’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score. Reading age or level counts on a list where at least one listing gives one, and a book whose listing gives none then scores zero on it. Where no listing gives one, the score is taken over the other 85 points. Books carry no warranty, so warranty is not scored.

How to choose the best detective novels classic

Start with Holmes

Volume I and Volume II together cover all 56 short stories and 4 novels, from A Study in Scarlet to The Hound of the Baskervilles. If you only buy one, Volume I starts the journey. For more mysteries, browse our thriller and mystery books.

Modern series starters

Crimson Thaw and The Devil’s Kitchen are both Book 1 of 4, clean entry points to modern series. Unnatural Murder is Book 8 of 30, so begin earlier in the Dead Cold Mysteries. For darker fare, see our dark detective novels.

Page count

Sherlock Holmes Volume I lists 1088 pages and Volume II lists 768; Unnatural Murder lists 222. The two modern series starters state no page count, so check the listing if length matters.

Before you buy

• Check the series number: Unnatural Murder is Book 8 of 30, so start earlier.
• Confirm the edition: the Bantam volumes are 1986 classics editions.
• Read the description for tone: modern procedurals versus Victorian classics.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Holmes volume first?

Volume I is Book 1 of 2 with A Study in Scarlet and The Sign of Four; Volume II is Book 2 of 2.

Are the modern books series starters?

Crimson Thaw and The Devil’s Kitchen are both Book 1 of 4; Unnatural Murder is Book 8 of 30.

Which is the longest?

Sherlock Holmes Volume I lists 1088 pages; Volume II lists 768.

Still deciding? Our top pickSherlock Holmes Vol I

Check price on Amazon

Related lists

See every fiction list. Also see our best dark detective novels.

More lists: browse fiction books.